Trusted by over 1M+ customers
Top Quirky Restaurants in Staten Island, NY
Ready to treat your guests to a culinary experience unlike any other? Staten Island, known for its diverse food culture and places like the trendy North Shore, has quirky restaurants waiting to be explored. Hop on Tagvenue's platform and immerse yourself in a world of distinctive dining establishments, from quaint eateries near Snug Harbor to avant-garde spots in South Beach. Our extensive selection, coupled with smart search filters, will streamline your hunt. Are you ready to savor the charm of Staten Island's one-of-a-kind restaurants? Explore our quirky restaurants in Staten Island today!
-
![Main Dining Room at Farington's Cafe and Restaurant in Staten Island, New York City, NY]()
from $50
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityMain Dining Room
35 guestsFarington's Cafe and RestaurantStaten Island, New York City, NYThe main dining room at Farington's Café and Restaurant accommodates up to 40 guests, featuring warm lighting and elegant table settings. Ideal for intimate gatherings like birthdays, private dinners, or small corporate events, -
![Entire Venue at Piccolino Restaurant in Staten Island, New York City, NY]()
from $49
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityEntire Venue
80 guestsPiccolino RestaurantStaten Island, New York City, NYPiccolinos NY is a family-owned fine dining Italian restaurant located at 3935 Amboy Rd in Staten Island We've been serving the Staten Island community for over 10 years! -
![Sage Room at Marbella in Stapleton, Staten Island, NY]()
from $1000
hire fee / per sessionCheck availabilitySage Room
75 guestsMarbellaStapleton, Staten Island, NYThe Sage Room is a warm, Mediterranean-inspired venue designed for everything from intimate dinners to full-blown celebrations. Whether you’re hosting a private gathering for 100 or combining it with Marbella to welcome up -
![Event Space at Brooklyn's Finest Pizza in Staten Island, New York City, NY]()
from $100
hire fee / per hourCheck availabilityEvent Space
40 guestsBrooklyn's Finest PizzaStaten Island, New York City, NYThe Event Space at Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is perfect for any occasion, from birthday parties to dining gatherings. With seating for up to 50 guests, this inviting venue offers a versatile and comfortable environment. -
![The Patio at District Bar NYC in Staten Island, New York City, NY]()
from $42
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityThe Patio
94 guestsDistrict Bar NYCStaten Island, New York City, NYThe patio is a great outdoor spot for any event, perfect for hanging out day or night. Whether for a sunny brunch or an evening party under the stars, this space has the right vibe. -
![Main Dining Room at Marbella in Stapleton, Staten Island, NY]()
from $2000
minimum spend / per dayCheck availabilityMain Dining Room
100 guestsMarbellaStapleton, Staten Island, NYThe space features plush teal banquettes and high-backed chairs that add a pop of color against soft neutral walls and elegant lighting. Tables are dressed in crisp white linens, giving the room a refined yet welcoming atmosphere. -
![Entire Venue at Mimmo's Brick Oven Pizza & Trattoria in Staten Island, New York City, NY]()
from $65
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityEntire Venue
55 guestsMimmo's Brick Oven Pizza & TrattoriaStaten Island, New York City, NYFrom our specialty pizza to our famous sandwiches, rustic southern Italian entrees, fine wines, a unique selection of Italian beers, homemade desserts, and a variety of after-dinner liquors, Mimmo's is sure to give you the -
![Entire Venue at Jac Mao in Staten Island, New York City, NY]()
from $40
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityEntire Venue
63 guestsJac MaoStaten Island, New York City, NYA well-stocked bar catches the eye, perfect for a drink before you eat. The room is set up so you can talk without others hearing, adding to the classy feel that makes Jac Mao a great place to eat. -
![Main Dining at District Bar NYC in Staten Island, New York City, NY]()
from $42
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityMain Dining
94 guestsDistrict Bar NYCStaten Island, New York City, NYThe Main Dining at District is perfect for hanging out or throwing a party. Bright neon lights and wooden decor create a fun and cozy atmosphere. Whether you're watching a game or celebrating something special, this room -
![Entire Venue at Vino Divino Winery in Charleston, Staten Island, NY]()
from $60
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityEntire Venue
100 guestsVino Divino WineryCharleston, Staten Island, NYFounded in 2003. Vino Divino is the first school of wine to open in Richmond County. We teach you how to craft your own wine using premium grapes from California, Chile and South Africa. -
![Inside Space at Main Street Coffee in Staten Island, New York City, NY]()
from $100
hire fee / per hourCheck availabilityInside Space
20 guestsMain Street CoffeeStaten Island, New York City, NYWe always appreciate the chance to help you organize an event so you can relax and have fun. Therefore, secure your private dining space as soon as possible and let us help you create a fantastic event! -
![Entire Space at Main Street Coffee in Staten Island, New York City, NY]()
from $600
hire fee / per hourCheck availabilityEntire Space
75 guestsMain Street CoffeeStaten Island, New York City, NYThe Coffee House's serene atmosphere and spacious outside patio, which can seat up to 75 people, make it the ideal place to relax and enjoy a meal. Our eating space is warm and inviting, and it receives a lot of natural light.
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
Capacity
Budget
Event Type
Area type
Venue type
Catering and drinks
Accessibility features
FAQs about Top Quirky Restaurants in Staten Island, NY
In Staten Island, prices of quirky restaurants average $50 per person. Costs vary depending on guest capacity, popularity, location, and amenities like sound systems or bar services. Extra charges may apply for custom catering, decor, or event planning services. Packages with add-ons, such as DJs, photo booths, or other entertainment services, can also increase the overall cost. Check out the typical price ranges in Staten Island, based on Tagvenue data from October 2025:
| From $42 | to $60 | per person |
| From $100 | to $400 | hire fee per hour |
| From $1000 | hire fee per event |
- Exclusive dining area or room
- Personalized menu options
- Professional wait staff and service team
- Customizable seating arrangements
- In-house audio and visual equipment
- Wi-Fi access
- Ample parking space or valet service
- Dedicated event coordinator or manager
- Specialty lighting options
- Access to in-house bar and bartender services
Renting a restaurant in Staten Island is a flexible option, perfect for numerous events. Whether it's a family reunion where everyone gathers to share stories over delicious food, or a corporate meeting set in a more relaxed and ambient atmosphere, a restaurant provides the ideal backdrop. Moreover, they're popular choices for intimate wedding receptions, allowing couples to celebrate their love story with close friends and family. Don't forget about milestone birthday parties or anniversary dinners; a quirky restaurant adds a touch of class and sophistication to your special day.
Joyce's Tavern: Located in the picturesque South Shore area, Joyce's Tavern is a testament to traditional Staten Island charm. This venue exudes a warm and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for those looking for a more homely and intimate setting. Their menu blends classic American dishes with a contemporary twist, ensuring every guest finds something they like.
Piccolino Restaurant: Located in Staten Island, Piccolino Restaurant stands out with its exquisite Italian cuisine and rustic ambiance. The elegant décor, combined with a menu bursting with authentic flavors, transports guests straight to the heart of Italy. Its intimate setting and top-notch service make it a preferred choice for many event organizers looking to impress their guests.
