Quirky Restaurants for Rent in New York City, NY

In New York City, prices of quirky restaurants average $2500 minimum spend per event. Costs vary depending on guest capacity, popularity, location, and amenities like sound systems or bar services. Extra charges may apply for custom catering, decor, or event planning services. Packages with add-ons, such as DJs, photo booths, or other entertainment services, can also increase the overall cost. Check out the typical price ranges in New York City, based on Tagvenue data:

Based on the popularity and user ratings on Tagvenue (updated August 2025), the best options include:

• Entire Venue at The Flatiron Room @ Giorgio's of Gramercy in Flatiron District - rated 5/5
  Our user said: ‘The space is fantastic! Our guests loved it. The food was incredible and the servers went above and beyond.’

• Avenida Rooftop at Avenida Cocina & Cócteles in Midtown Manhattan - rated 5/5
  Our user said: ‘I highly recommend booking this place if you're planning an event.’

• Entire Restaurant at BarDough NYC in Hell's Kitchen - rated 4.9/5
  Our user said: ‘10/10 recommend! The staff was great, the space is perfect, great sound system, and really yummy food!’

First things first, you should think of the budget you have for the event. This will determine many things, such as the guest list, venue size and location. Remember to book the space at least a few weeks in advance. Also, New York is a busy city with plenty of people celebrating something every day, so it’ll be useful to have a few dates in mind for your party. Typically, the most sought-after times for booking unique restaurant venues are weekends, particularly Friday and Saturday evenings. These days are popular for birthdays and other celebrations. Additionally, seasonal peaks in late spring through early fall see higher demand due to the pleasant weather, making outdoor spaces especially attractive. 

There are plenty of areas in New York that you should check out for quirky venues.

• Greenwich Village: This area has a charming and comfy setting, perfect for creating memorable, personalized events that require a unique ambiance. A standout option here is the Baby No More - Private Room at Baby Brasa.
• East Village: Renting a restaurant here means tapping into a lively, artsy vibe with cuisines as varied as the community. It is perfect for casual gatherings or themed parties. The Whole Venue at Whiskey Cellar NYC captures this spirit perfectly.
• Lower East Side: The compact, innovative restaurants in this neighborhood are fantastic for fashion-forward events and gatherings that seek a blend of modern chic and urban edge. A good example is the Full Venue at La Victoria.
• DUMBO, Brooklyn: It offers scenic views of the Manhattan skyline and the Brooklyn Bridge. DUMBO has stylish, upscale restaurants that are a good fit for elegant events. A prime example is the Entire Venue at Randolph Beer DUMBO. 

If you’re based in Manhattan, we suggest you have a look around Tribeca, Hell’s Kitchen, Chelsea and SoHo. For any Brooklynites we recommend checking out the quirky spots in Brooklyn Heights, Bushwick, and Williamsburg. We’re sure you won’t be disappointed with the selection of quirky spaces in Queens, especially those located in Astoria and Flushing.

• The Garden at Vineapple Cafe - If you’re looking for a quirky setting, this Brooklyn Heights spot is perfect for brunches and cocktail parties. Walls adorned with paintings, lush green wonderland and colorful furniture will brighten your day!
• Monk McGinn’s - A great establishment with old-world touches where you’ll experience a truly spectacular setting and cocktails. High ceilings, brick walls, as well as exposed pipes and beams will take you back in time to a 1920s tavern.
• Wandering Barman - Located on the outskirts of Downtown Brooklyn, Wandering Barman is a cocktail tasting room offering the best in handcrafted cocktails. The interior is a neutral gray and the space feels elegant. This venue does not provide food but has a dedicated space to set up your own catering.
   

For exclusive venue hire, consider the Full Venue at La Victoria, located in the Meatpacking District. This venue has a large space with a two-floor layout, perfect for large events. Another fantastic option is the Entire Venue at La Caverna, located on the Lower East Side in Manhattan, which provides a lively atmosphere that allows you to make a grand statement for your celebration.

If you are planning smaller, more private events, partial venue hire options are also available. The Bar Society First Floor in the Financial District of Manhattan, has a cozy yet stylish space ideal for casual get-togethers or private parties. The Cassette Room at Black Tap NYC in Midtown Manhattan also provides a dynamic, retro-inspired environment with a fun and energetic vibe perfect for birthdays and after-work parties.