A function room with exposed brick walls, mosaic pendant lighting, and small candlelit tables at Jake's Dilemma.

Jake's Dilemma

Bar

#9 of 1386 Birthday Party venues in New York City
#7 of 1188 Birthday Dinner venues in New York City
  14 reviews  â€“ 
430 Amsterdam Avenue, New York, NY 10024 –
Upper West Side, New York City, NY
From $1200
min. spend
Up to 340
seats
Up to 350
standing
Venue offers catering
American
cuisine
Parking available
Manager's avatar
Christine EDBME
Your Personal Event Manager from Eat, Drink & Be Merry Events
Response rate: 99%
Response time: Within 3 hours
Message host
Partnered with Tagvenue for 2 years
This manager has been a trusted partner of Tagvenue, consistently recognised by customers for their reliability.
Excellent communication - 4.8/5
50 verified clients rated their communication with the venue manager as 4.8. They appreciated the manager's professionalism and quick response times.
Message host

Venue overview

Jake’s Dilemma is a lively sports bar on Amsterdam Ave, NYC, known for its diverse beer selection and foosball games. Perfect for casual parties and gatherings with a vibrant, friendly vibe.

This is an AI-generated summary based on client reviews and venue profile

Spaces for hire at Jake's Dilemma

The Oak Cellar at Jake's Dilemma
The Oak Cellar
Function Room
·
Private space
50 seats
60 standing
Welcome to The Oak Cellar, a uniquely designed party room that exudes the charm of a European wine cellar with an industrial twist. This intimate space accommodates up to 60 guests and boasts stoned archways, mosaic tiles, brick walls, cobblestone floors, and stained-glass accents. The cozy downstairs party room comes complete with a private bar, ...
Alcohol licence until 4:00 am
Unavailable: Alcohol licence extension
PA system / music speakers
Play your own music
from $1200 minimum spend
Pricing updated by venue 7 months ago
Enquire now
Riverside Room and Commons at Jake's Dilemma
Riverside Room and Commons
Bar
·
Shared space
60 seats
100 standing
Introducing the Riverside Room and Commons at Jake's Dilemma, a versatile event space that combines rustic charm with modern elegance. This spacious venue features wooden floors and brick walls, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for any occasion. Whether you're hosting a corporate gathering, wedding reception, or social event, this bar offers...
Alcohol licence until 4:00 am
Unavailable: Alcohol licence extension
PA system / music speakers
Play your own music
from $2200 minimum spend
Pricing updated by venue 7 months ago
Enquire now
Riverside Room at Jake's Dilemma
Riverside Room
Dining Room
·
Private space
20 seats
35 standing
Step into the Riverside Room at Jake's Dilemma, a hidden gem tucked away in the back, offering a cozy and intimate party space. The vibrant blue walls bring life to the room, creating a lively atmosphere for your event. The private bar, adorned with charming pendants, adds a touch of elegance, while the decorative floor tiles make the space truly u...
Alcohol licence until 4:00 am
Unavailable: Alcohol licence extension
PA system / music speakers
Play your own music
from $1200 minimum spend
Pricing updated by venue 7 months ago
Enquire now
Whole Space at Jake's Dilemma
Whole Space
Bar
·
Whole venue
340 seats
350 standing
This versatile space is designed to host up to 350 people in a standing arrangement, making it perfect for large events. Enjoy a friendly game of foosball while sipping on a wide selection of beverages from our bar. Explore other unique spaces such as The Oak Seller, Riverside Room, and Commons to craft an unforgettable experience for your guests. ...
Alcohol licence until 4:00 am
Unavailable: Alcohol licence extension
PA system / music speakers
Play your own music
from $6000 minimum spend
Pricing updated by venue 7 months ago
Enquire now

Reviews and ratings

4.9
1 new review from verified user within the last 6 months
4 recent guests highly rated amenities, cleanliness, location and service quality
Amenities
5.0
Cleanliness
5.0
Location
5.0
Service quality
5.0
Value for money
5.0
Catering
4.8
Communication
4.8
Verified reviews come from Tagvenue users. All reviews are checked by our team to uphold our trust and safety standards.
MA
Margaret A.
Verified review
Birthday Party · 35 guests · December 2025
The staff at the venue was super helpful - Austin, the bartender was great, and Christine was amazingly helpful getting all the arrangements and catering in place. We had a great time and would highly recommend this venue to others.
4.9
MA
Margaret A.
Verified review
Excellent communication
Christine was super helpful and provided good advice on catering, numbers, etc.
5.0
C
Carolyn
Verified review
Engagement Party · 50 guests · February 2025
Wonderful venue - efficient and friendly staff - good food. Perfect place to host a party!
5.0
CP
Cilla P.
Verified review
Birthday Party · 25 guests · February 2025
Great staff! Room is private, a good size and has personal bathroom disconnected from public bar. Option to play own music and full bar. Had a great time; would book again!
5.0

Prices and opening hours

Sunday
12:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200–$6000 min. spend
Whole Space
12:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $6000 min. spend
The Oak Cellar
12:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room
12:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room and Commons
12:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $2200 min. spend
Monday
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200–$6000 min. spend
Whole Space
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $6000 min. spend
The Oak Cellar
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room and Commons
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $2200 min. spend
Tuesday
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200–$6000 min. spend
Whole Space
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $6000 min. spend
The Oak Cellar
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room and Commons
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $2200 min. spend
Wednesday
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200–$6000 min. spend
Whole Space
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $6000 min. spend
The Oak Cellar
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room and Commons
3:00 pm – 2:00 am
from $2200 min. spend
Thursday
3:00 pm – 3:00 am
from $1200–$6000 min. spend
Whole Space
3:00 pm – 3:00 am
from $6000 min. spend
The Oak Cellar
3:00 pm – 3:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room
3:00 pm – 3:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room and Commons
3:00 pm – 3:00 am
from $2200 min. spend
Friday
3:00 pm – 4:00 am
from $1200–$6000 min. spend
Whole Space
3:00 pm – 4:00 am
from $6000 min. spend
The Oak Cellar
3:00 pm – 4:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room
3:00 pm – 4:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room and Commons
3:00 pm – 4:00 am
from $2200 min. spend
Saturday
12:00 pm – 4:00 am
from $1200–$6000 min. spend
Whole Space
12:00 pm – 4:00 am
from $6000 min. spend
The Oak Cellar
12:00 pm – 4:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room
12:00 pm – 4:00 am
from $1200 min. spend
Riverside Room and Commons
12:00 pm – 4:00 am
from $2200 min. spend
Pricing updated by venue 7 months ago

Best Price guarantee: you will always pay the same price as booking directly with the venue, and we never add hidden or processing fees.

Facilities and catering options

Up to 350
standing
Up to 340
seats
In-house catering
American
cuisine
Parking available
Alcohol provided
Unavailable: External catering allowed
Unavailable: Accommodation available
Unavailable: Promoted / ticketed events
Unavailable: BYO alcohol

About Jake's Dilemma

Jake's Dilemma is a Trusted Tagvenue Partner, validated by the Tagvenue team with a record of successful bookings on the platform.

Welcome to Jake’s Dilemma, a lively sports bar situated at 430 Amsterdam Ave, New York. Nestled along the vibrant Amsterdam Avenue strip, this casual bar is a favorite among the young crowd, celebrated for its diverse beer selection and entertaining foosball games.

The atmosphere at Jake’s Dilemma is laid-back and friendly, providing the perfect setting to unwind after a long day or enjoy a night out with friends. Whether you're a sports enthusiast eager to catch the latest game or simply in the mood for good company and a cold beer, Jake’s Dilemma has everything you need for a great time. Book now and experience the lively vibes for yourself!

www.jakesdilemmanyc.com •
+1 212-580-0556

FAQ

At Jake's Dilemma, the following catering options are available:

  • In-house catering service is available

  • Paid parking facilities are available nearby

Here are some event spends from guests who recently held events at Jake's Dilemma:

  • The Oak Cellar hosting 40 guests: $1940
  • Riverside Room and Commons hosting 40 guests: $1320
  • Riverside Room hosting 30 guests: $1374

For detailed pricing tailored to your event, please contact the venue.

Jake's Dilemma is located at 430 Amsterdam Avenue, in Upper West Side, New York City, NY.

Find more similar venues in New York City, NY

Over 17k venues
•
Trusted by 1M+ customers
Please enter a valid number of guests
Please select a city

Trusted by over 1M+ customers

Similar venues

Fashion Avenue
from $205
hire fee / per hour
Event Venue
Private space
20
40
RPM Underground
(47)
Midtown West, New York City, NY
Whole Venue
from $3500
minimum spend / per session
Nightclub
Whole venue
120
225
The Red Pavilion
(4)
Bushwick, New York City, NY
Versatile Studio/OpenLayout
from $150
hire fee / per hour
Event Venue
Whole venue
200
300
Manhattan Space Rentals
(1)
Garment District, New York City, NY
Entire Venue
from $5000
minimum spend / per day
Bar
Whole venue
40
220
Madeline's
(20)
Greenpoint, New York City, NY
Entire Venue
from $300
per person / per session
Restaurant
Whole venue
350
450
Empire Steak House East
(6)
Midtown East, New York City, NY
Event Space
from $285
hire fee / per hour
Event Venue
Whole venue
200
150
Hit Central Studios
Gravesend, New York City, NY
Entire Venue
from $30
per person / per session
Restaurant
Whole venue
200
500
Palma Verde
(1)
Times Square, New York City, NY
Entire Space with Patio
from $55
per person / per session
Restaurant
Whole venue
260
500
Redeye Grill
(1)
Midtown West, New York City, NY
ILA Rooftop
from $1000
hire fee / per hour
Penthouse
Private space
125
200
ILA Penthouse
(9)
Chelsea, New York City, NY
Main Ballroom & Mezzanine
from $10000
hire fee / per session
Hall
Private space
300
400
HK Hall
(3)
Hell's Kitchen, New York City, NY
Birthday Party
from $4500
minimum spend / per session
Restaurant
Private space
100
250
Madam Mikette’s
(3)
Midtown Manhattan, New York City, NY
Event Hall 2
from $3000
hire fee / per day
Meeting Centre
Private space
200
250
NYC Seminar & Conference Center
(16)
NoMad, New York City, NY
Entire Hall
from $12000
minimum spend / per day
Bar
Whole venue
220
400
Houston Hall
(1)
South Village, New York City, NY
Whole Venue
from $75
per person / per session
Bar
Whole venue
300
350
Off the Wagon
(3)
South Village, New York City, NY
Event Space
from $725
hire fee / per hour
Community Centre
Private space
250
200
Downtown Community Television Center
(1)
Chinatown, New York City, NY
Entire Space - Buyout
from $6000
minimum spend / per session
Pub
Whole venue
80
175
Folly NYC
(17)
South Village, New York City, NY
MAD Room
from $65
per person / per session
Bar
Semi-private area
63
100
5th and Mad
(37)
Murray Hill, New York City, NY
Maison Nur
from $15
per person / per day
Restaurant
Whole venue
125
250
Maison Nur
Murray Hill, New York City, NY
Entire Venue
from $1200
hire fee / per hour
Warehouse
Whole venue
150
280
Giant warehouse with 3 sand volleyball courts
(2)
Long Island City, New York City, NY
Entire Venue
from $50
per person / per session
Bar
Whole venue
200
325
Unique Lounge & Billiards
Staten Island, New York City, NY
Entire Venue
from $5100
minimum spend / per session
Bar
Whole venue
200
200
The High Note
(10)
Midtown Manhattan, New York City, NY
KAI studio
from $850
hire fee / per hour
Event Venue
Whole venue
225
350
KAI studio
(1)
Crown Heights, New York City, NY
Entire Venue
from $2325
minimum spend / per session
Bar
Whole venue
55
55
Gadfly Bar
(18)
Chelsea, New York City, NY

Explore other spaces in the area

430 Amsterdam Avenue, New York, NY 10024
Public transportation
Parking
Hotels
Public transportation
  • Subway 79 St 0.1 mi
  • Bus Amsterdam Av/W 81 St 0.1 mi
  • Bus Amsterdam Av/W 79 St 0.1 mi
  • Bus Broadway/W 79 St 0.1 mi
Parking
  • Parking Parking - 214-216 W 80th St, New York 0.1 mi
  • Parking Impark Parking - 200 W 79th St, New York 0.1 mi
Hotels
  • The Lucerne Hotel 0.1 mi

Jake's Dilemma is popular for

Restaurant Party Private Dining Birthday Party Bar Engagement Party Holiday Party Corporate Event Event Venues in Upper West Side, NY

Tagvenue regularly reviews published venues to ensure the information is accurate and up to date. If you notice anything unusual in this listing, please report it.

United States > New York City > Manhattan > Upper West Side > Jake's Dilemma