Quirky Restaurants for Rent in Long Island, NY

Booking costs of quirky restaurants average $55 per person. Costs vary depending on guest capacity, popularity, location, and amenities like sound systems or bar services. Extra charges may apply for custom catering, decor, or event planning services. Packages with add-ons, such as DJs, photo booths, or other entertainment services, can also increase the overall cost. Check out the typical price ranges in Long Island, based on Tagvenue data:

You'll find quirky restaurants in various sizes, from smaller spots to larger venues; keep in mind that the type of space and your chosen layout will affect the capacity! Below you can see the typical venue sizes in Long Island, together with the standard prices in each size range, based on Tagvenue data (October 2026):

Smaller quirky restaurants usually fit up to 45 guests seated. Here are some great options in Long Island, based on Tagvenue data as of October 2026:

• Patio at Mable's Smokehouse - outdoor space for 30 guests
  Venue said: Features: The patio provides fixed bench seating plus movable tables and chairs and a solid painted floor suitable for dining. The space also has street-level, step-free access and clear side panels that protect from wind...

• Upstairs Area at Sheep by Barashka, rated 5/5 - event space for 35 guests
  Venue said: Ideal for: The space suits small seated dinners and relaxed, social gatherings that benefit from a quieter, contained setting rather than the main restaurant floor.

• Harris Bar at Osteria Brooklyn, rated 5/5 - bar for 25 guests
  Venue said: Welcome to the Harris Bar Room, a unique and intimate space that is perfect for small gatherings and special occasions. With the ability to seat up to 25 guests, this cozy and inviting space is perfect for intimate dinners,

Cheap quirky restaurants in Long Island start from $35 per person or $150 hire fee per hour. Check out these budget-friendly spaces you can book through Tagvenue, as of October 2026:

• Eatery at Udom Thai, from $35 per person (up to 40 guests seated)
  Venue said: Celebrate your special moments in style at Udom Thai! Our authentic Thai restaurant in New York has all the ingredients for a perfect night. From mouthwatering cuisine to an atmosphere that will make you feel like you're...

• Palenque Venue at Palenque, from $150 hire fee per hour (up to 35 guests seated)
  Venue said: Palenque Restaurant and Arepa & Empanada Factory, located in East Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is dedicated to providing delicious ‘homestyle’ cooking to all New York City families, students, athletes and people who are dedicated...

• 138 SOCIAL EXPERIENCE at 138 BK, from $100 hire fee per event (up to 12 guests seated)
  Venue said: 138 Social Experience is a shared lounge with restaurant-style seating arranged along a long banquette. Its layout supports relaxed dining and easy conversation.