Please enter a valid number of guests
Please enter a location
Trusted by over 1M+ customers
Top Quirky Restaurants in Long Island, NY
Long Island’s quirky restaurants are as great as your next party’s gonna be! If you're looking for a cheap and cheerful diner, a fusion spot, or a cozy, romantic hideaway, you’ll find plenty of unusual dinner spots that serve up delicious eats. Hosting a kids’ birthday party? Try a fun-themed café in Garden City or a retro-style burger joint in Oyster Bay. Want a laid-back night out with friends? Head to Patchogue for the best gastropubs, or Huntington for global flavors and Instagram-worthy decor. From hole-in-the-wall ramen joints to seafood spots with pirate decor, Long Island does quirky dining like no other. Whether it’s a casual date night, a big family gathering, or a celebration with friends, your perfect spot is just a click away!
-
![Private Room at Pizzette in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $25
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityPrivate Room
50 guestsPizzetteNew York City, Long Island, NY
#Supervenue
MMithila D.
“Loved the fountain room and it was perfect for an intimate get together.” -
![Entire Venue at Lovebirds Wine Bar + Bistro in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $500
hire fee / per sessionCheck availabilityEntire Venue
35 guestsLovebirds Wine Bar + BistroNew York City, Long Island, NY
#Supervenue
LLinda W.
“The event space was gorgeous, food was great, and the pricing was reasonable.” -
![Living Room at Ainslie in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $4000
minimum spend / per sessionCheck availabilityLiving Room
50 guestsAinslieNew York City, Long Island, NYSSarah P.
“The staff was awesome and the rooftop was the perfect venue for my party.” -
![Entire Venue at 5C Cafe and Cultural Center in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $150
hire fee / per hourCheck availabilityEntire Venue
31 guests5C Cafe and Cultural CenterNew York City, Long Island, NYEErin S.
“They had all the equipment I needed and were communicative.” -
![Whole Venue at Pizzette in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $25
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityWhole Venue
75 guestsPizzetteNew York City, Long Island, NY
#Supervenue
JJade C.
“Great Service. Kind owner! Lovely space!” -
![Entire Venue at Moldova Restaurant in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $150
hire fee / per dayCheck availabilityEntire Venue
120 guestsMoldova RestaurantNew York City, Long Island, NYThe full buyout of Moldova Restaurant in New York. We have the main dining room with the capacity of 80 people, and the back 'garden' room with the capacity of 50 people, you may reserve each or both. -
![Mezzazine at Patrizia's of Maspeth in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $55
minimum spend / per sessionCheck availabilityMezzazine
50 guestsPatrizia's of MaspethNew York City, Long Island, NYMezzanine is a semi-private space located in Patrizia's restaurant. It allows for events of up to 50 people. You can enjoy an exceptional menu while enjoying time with your loved ones. -
![Entire Venue at Coquito Blu in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $500
hire fee / per hourCheck availabilityEntire Venue
190 guestsCoquito BluNew York City, Long Island, NYModern Latin Kitchen, Bar, and Event Space Two Levels with restrooms on both floors and an outdoor deck with free parking on the premises right behind the restaurant. -
![Main Dining Area at Kasthamandap Restaurant & Bar in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $55
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityMain Dining Area
31 guestsKasthamandap Restaurant & BarNew York City, Long Island, NYKasthamandap is a museum restaurant and bar serving modern Nepalese cuisine. Within the venue, guests can choose from indoor or outdoor dining spaces that can also be used for private events. -
![Entire Restaurant at Kitchen at Cobble Hill in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $3500
minimum spend / per sessionCheck availabilityEntire Restaurant
105 guestsKitchen at Cobble HillNew York City, Long Island, NYWe're not your average restaurant. You might come for the great-tasting food, but we hope you stay for the experience. We're about more than just a meal. -
![Entire Venue at Osteria Brooklyn in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $75
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityEntire Venue
165 guestsOsteria BrooklynNew York City, Long Island, NYOsteria Brooklyn is a stunning and versatile venue, featuring four unique and beautiful spaces that can be combined to create the perfect setting for any occasion. -
![The Dining Room at The Upper Crust - Queens in New York City, Long Island, NY]()
from $45
per person / per sessionCheck availabilityThe Dining Room
50 guestsThe Upper Crust - QueensNew York City, Long Island, NYThe Upper Crust - Queens' Private Room is a roomy and cozy venue for bar mitzvahs, bat mitzvahs, and other special events. It provides a cozy and private setting for your event, with space for 50–60 people to sit.
- 1
- 2
- 3
- ...
- 11
Capacity
Budget
Event Type
Area type
Venue type
Catering and drinks
Accessibility features
Find Affordable Unusual Restaurants in Long Island
from $20
per person / per session
per person / per session
Entire Venue
50
50
Bagel Point
New York City, Long Island, NY
The bright venue can accommodate a total of 50 guests, in its inside and outside areas. Located off the Nassau Ave stop on the G Train, Bagel Point brings joy bite by bite to Brooklynites.
from $35
per person / per session
per person / per session
Entire Venue
80
85
Cena
New York City, Long Island, NY
Our all-inclusive packages are tailored to suit your budget, so you can revel in your special occasion stress-free. With our expertise in event planning and delectable cuisine, you're in for an experience that's second to
from $35
per person / per session
per person / per session
Inside
40
45
Cena
New York City, Long Island, NY
Natural light dances around the room, illuminating the thoughtfully designed setting. Whether you're here for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, our interior offers an inviting backdrop that's as flavorful as the dishes we
from $35
per person / per session
per person / per session
Entire Venue
46
75
Vesuvio
New York City, Long Island, NY
Step into Vesuvio Restaurant & Pizzeria, where the atmosphere is both cozy and elegant, making it an ideal setting for any occasion. The space is beautifully designed with rustic brick walls, polished wood furnishings, and
from $35
per person / per session
per person / per session
Entire Venue
38
40
Cena Cantina
New York City, Long Island, NY
And oh, the drinks! Each sip is a symphony of flavors that'll awaken your taste buds. But that's not all, our service is the cherry on top. Prepare to be pampered beyond your wildest expectations!
from $500
minimum spend / per session
minimum spend / per session
Indoor Space
30
50
Panzón
New York City, Long Island, NY
Our restaurant is a perfect place for enjoying a delicious meal or drink in comfort and style. Salut!
Host Your Dream Wedding in One of Our Best Restaurants
from $45
per person / per session
per person / per session
Entire Venue
60
80
Mable's Smokehouse
New York City, Long Island, NY
Mable's is a unique and rustic restaurant that can host a wide variety of events. We have held many weddings, rehearsal dinners and parties of all types here at Mable's.
from $150
per person / per session
per person / per session
The Rooftop Lounge
100
150
Vetro Restaurant & Lounge
New York City, Long Island, NY
Take your celebration to another level at our Rooftop. This modern, chic room is perfect for any kind of event. From birthdays, communions to weddings and corporate events, with the incredible features of a retractable roof,
from $2000
minimum spend / per day
minimum spend / per day
Entire Venue
280
500
Farm to People
New York City, Long Island, NY
Farm to People’s venue is a spacious, versatile space with beamed ceilings, wide windows, and warm lighting, creating a rustic charm ideal for events like weddings, parties, dinners, concerts, and talks.
from $55
per person / per session
per person / per session
Entire Venue
40
50
Alta Calidad
New York City, Long Island, NY
A bright and relaxed atmosphere for you and your guests to dine! Our restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor spaces, providing the perfect setting for any occasion.
from $50
per person / per session
per person / per session
Whole Venue
50
80
Il Vizio
Long Island, NY
Looking for a spacious venue for your next event? Il Vizio in Massapequa offers the entire restaurant for exclusive use, accommodating up to 80 guests.
from $47
per person / per session
per person / per session
Entire Venue
50
65
El Born
New York City, Long Island, NY
El Born offers you the perfect space for your cocktail hour / stand up parties. We serve a pre fix menu with passed tapas and a paella station plus dessert.
Book a Festive Restaurant for Your Christmas Dinner
from $60
per person / per session
per person / per session
Little Cantina
40
70
Fresco's Cantina (Original Location)
New York City, Long Island, NY
You will love the intimacy offered and the ultra VIP “buy out” experience. The venue can accommodate up to 70 guests standing or 40 for a seated reception.
from $85
per person / per session
per person / per session
Entire Venue
120
130
Native Restaurant and Lounge
New York City, Long Island, NY
Native Restaurant and Lounge offers a chic and modern space perfect for hosting large seated events with a capacity of 120 guests. The venue’s sleek design, highlighted by glowing purple lighting, creates a vibrant atmosphere,
from $35
per person / per session
per person / per session
Eatery
40
45
Udom Thai
New York City, Long Island, NY
Celebrate your special moments in style at Udom Thai! Our authentic Thai restaurant in New York has all the ingredients for a perfect night. From mouthwatering cuisine to an atmosphere that will make you feel like you're
from $6000
hire fee / per session
hire fee / per session
Entire Venue
46
75
Balvanera NYC
New York City, Long Island, NY
Full Buyout of this one and only Balvanera Restaurant in New York City. It would be our pleasure to host your personal or corporate event. Our space is a beautiful place with a maximum capacity of 75 guests, perfect for daytime
from $100
per person / per session
per person / per session
Patio
40
45
Verde on Smith
New York City, Long Island, NY
Looking for a unique event space? Verde on Smith has you covered! Our stunning outdoor dining room is perfect for any occasion, from cocktail receptions to seated dinners.
from $75
per person / per session
per person / per session
Private Green House
50
50
Osteria Brooklyn
New York City, Long Island, NY
Welcome to our Private Green House, an exclusive and fully private outdoor space that is perfect for any occasion. This beautiful and unique setting is designed to comfortably accommodate up to 50 guests, providing an intimate
Popular Restaurants to Book for Your Upcoming Bridal Shower
from $50
per person / per session
per person / per session
Private Patio
30
48
Levantine
New York City, Long Island, NY
It is perfect for private dinners, birthdays, baby and bridal showers, and corporate gatherings, offering a world of intimacy while maintaining the pulse of Williamsburg.
from $25
per person / per session
per person / per session
Bar Room
25
40
Pizzette
New York City, Long Island, NY
#Supervenue
J
Jade C.
“Great Service. Kind owner! Lovely space!”
“Great Service. Kind owner! Lovely space!”
from $65
per person / per session
per person / per session
Grand Room
62
100
Sevan Restaurant & Catering
New York City, Long Island, NY
The Grand Room has a capacity of 100 people. This space is suitable for larger events such as dinners, wedding receptions, birthday celebrations, and more!
from $42
per person / per session
per person / per session
Entire Restaurant
70
70
Papazzio
New York City, Long Island, NY
Come experience the delicious cuisine and amazing atmosphere of this unique Italian restaurant or book us to celebrate your special event. We will make sure you and your guests have a great time at our restaurant!
from $70
per person / per session
per person / per session
Banquet Room
110
120
Marco Polo
New York City, Long Island, NY
A Brooklyn landmark for 40 years, with a new menu that will appeal to both long-term guests and new-generation diners. Choose our Banquet beautifully renovated room for your next event, where you can have your event hosted
from $1000
minimum spend / per evening
minimum spend / per evening
Dining Room
35
50
Sol Et Soleil
New York City, Long Island, NY
With a maximum capacity of 70 guests (35 indoor, 22 patio) and curated food and beverage packages to suit every occasion, this venue is ideal for birthday dinners, baby showers, bridal showers, or cocktail parties, and our
FAQs about Top Quirky Restaurants in Long Island, NY
Booking costs of quirky restaurants average $55 per person. Costs vary depending on guest capacity, popularity, location, and amenities like sound systems or bar services. Extra charges may apply for custom catering, decor, or event planning services. Packages with add-ons, such as DJs, photo booths, or other entertainment services, can also increase the overall cost. Check out the typical price ranges in Long Island, based on Tagvenue data from December 2025:
| From $47 | to $75 | per person |
| From $1800 | to $4500 | minimum spend per event |
| From $150 | to $500 | hire fee per hour |
You'll find quirky restaurants in various sizes, from smaller spots to larger venues; keep in mind that the type of space and your chosen layout will affect the capacity! Below you can see the typical venue sizes in Long Island, together with the standard prices in each size range, based on Tagvenue data (December 2025):
| Small | up to 45 guests | prices average $600 hire fee per event |
| Medium | between 50 and 75 guests | prices average $3500 minimum spend per event |
| Large | over 85 guests | prices average $3500 minimum spend per event |
Page last updated in December 2025
To provide you with relevant information, our pages are refreshed using an algorithm that aggregates real-time data, including bookings, reviews, and venue updates.